Religion 353b: Seminar Islamic Philosophy and Theology

Topic for Spring, 2004: The Mystical Thought of Muhyiddin Ibn `Arabi (d. 638 H, 1240 CE).

New: Jesus Bezel Sample Short Essay

James Morris, "Seekings God's Face"

This seminar will focus upon Ibn `Arabi's most widely read work, The Bezels of Wisdom (Fusus al-Hikam), sometimes translated as Ring Settings of Wisdom or even Ringstones of Wisdom.

The work consists of 27 chapters, each of which articulates an aspect of Ibn `Arabi's mystical philosophy as it is exemplified by the wisdom of one of the prophets. It begins with a chapter on Adam and ends with a chapter on Muhammad.

In addition, we will read Ibn `Arabi's most famous collection of poetry, the Interpreter of Desires, sometimes translated as the Translator of Desires, or the Translation of Desires, or even the Biographer of Desires (Turjuman al-Ashwaq). We will focus on the relationship of love lyric to mystical philosophy and the major controversies that surrounded the original publication of these love lyrics.

Required Books:

The prerequisite this course is the consent of the instructor. That consent is based upon either a) significant previous study of Islam as a tradition and Sufism (Islamic mysticism) within Islam OR b) the willingness to fill in this background by reading substantial sections of one book before taking the course and by making up other readings during the first weeks of the course. Previous courses in religion, English, or comparative literature are also highly recommended; the requirements of the course focus on close analysis of texts of considerable literary complexity.

Required reading for those who have not taken a course on Islam or Sufism is the book Early Islamic Mysticism (EIM), pp. 5-74, which must be read and absorbed before the first class of the semester. These pages include a) a general introduction to Sufism up to the time of Ibn `Arabi, b) the Qur'anic passages that are absolutely essential for any reading of Ibn `Arabi, c) the passages from the Mi`raj (ascent of Muhammad) traditions that Ibn `Arabi evokes continually, and d) the poetic tradition of which Ibn `Arabi was an integral part. The entire class will be reading these sections, as well as other sections from EIM. Pages 5-74 of EIM include the fundamental material from the Islamic tradition and Arabic literature that will need to be mastered to understand the texts of Ibn `Arabi, who alludes to such material continually.

Qur'ans will be available on reserve. (The Qur'anic subtexts are noted in the translations of Ibn `Arabi and should be consulted. It is vital not to confuse the Qur'anic story of a particular prophet such as Abraham or Moses with the Biblical version, which will be similar in some ways and very different in others; Ibn `Arabi obviously alludes to the Qur'anic story).

The class will be assigned secondary readings from books that will be available on reserve, including other books by William Chittick (The Sufi Path of Knowledge), Claude Addas (The Quest for the Red Sulfur), Stephen Hirtenstein (The Unlimited Mercifier), Toshihiko Izutsu (Sufism and Taoism), Sachiko Murata (The Tao of Zen), Miguel Chodkievicz (The Seal of the Saints), Alexander Knysh (Ibn `Arabi in the Sufi Tradition) and other texts to be discussed the first day of class. Sections or aspects of these writings, or parts of them, will also be selected by students (or assigned to students who prefer) for oral reports and short papers.

Recommended readings:

Students who might have a reading knowledge of Arabic will be offered assistance in reading some passages in both English and Arabic.

Students who think they may need accomodations in this course because of the impact of a disability are encouraged to meet with me privately early in the semester. Students should also contact Rick Webb, Coordinator, Office of disabilities Services (rwebb@haverford.edu, 610-896-1290) to verify their eligibility for reasonable accomodations as soon as possible. Early contact will help to avoid unnecessary inconvenience and delays.

Course Requirements: short papers (25%), Class Attendance and Participation (25%), Final Paper (50%).

The final paper will be 12-14 pages and will involve significant analysis of primary texts from the Bezels of Wisdom and/or poems from The Interpreter of Desires (aka Turjuman al-Ashwaq, TA). Primary texts can include those discussed in class and/or those not discussed. Students writing on the Bezels of Wisdom may focus on one or more (but generally not more than three) of the "bezels." Other texts from Ibn al-`Arabi and secondary writings should be used and integrated into the essay as appropriate. Students are welcome to show me drafts of the final paper for ungraded comments and discussion at any time prior to the end of classes.

The short papers will include a discussion of one of the bezels, one of the poems by Ibn al-`Arabi, and a critical report on an article or chapter of a book relevant to the class. Both the short papers will also form the background for an oral discussion, led by the student, on the texts to which the short paper is dedicated. The short papers are not to be read in class, but to be finished before the class session in which the oral discussion "opening" is handed in. The short papers should be no longer than 1,500 words each (preferably between 1000-1200 words). The oral reports will be given evaluations of strengths and weaknesses, but the grading will not be quantitative; rather it is figured into the class attendance and participation part of the course.

Tentative Syllabus of Primary Text Readings

(note, class is based upon reading of passages from primary texts in class and the central primary texts relevant to the day's class must be brought to class)

Week 01 (01/22)

EIM 5-74 Introduction to Sufism and its Sources BW 51-60; Fass Adam, translation 2

Week 02 (01/29)

EIM 75-96, BW 1-50, 60-81 Intro to Ibn `Arabi and the Adam Chapter, Seth and Noah. Marie report on Hirtenstein biography of Ibn al-`Arabi.

No Class (02/05) class time will be divided into small groups or individual meetings scheduled on 01/29

Week 04 (02/12)

BW 82-95 Enoch and Abraham (Patrick reporting), EIM 97-170 Qushayri and Rabi`a 196-211 Sarraj

Week 05 (02/19)

BW 96-110 Isaac (Jawaad reporting) and Ishmael, Matthew report on Sufis of Andalusia, EIM 212-250 Bistami

Week 06 (02/26)

BW 111-127 Jacob, and Joseph (Splinter reporting) EIM 171-195 Muhasibi, TA, 24

Week 07 (03/04)

BW 128-155 Hud, Salih, and Shu`ayb (Kira Reporting), TA Intro, poems 1-11

spring break (03/11)  

Week 08 (03/18)

BW 172-186 Jesus (Matthew reporting), Junayd, TA poems 12-25

Week 09 (03/25)

BW 187-197 Solomon (Marie reporting), Arabic Poetic Tradition, TA poems 25-38

Week 10 (04/01)

BW 228-235 Elias, TA Arabic poetic tradition, poems 38-61, Kira reporting (topic to be announced)

Week 11 (04/08):

BW 249-266 Moses, TA focus on selected poems, Ibn Sina (Splinter reporting)

Week 12 (04/15)

BW TA poems 20-30 Chittick's Imaginal Worlds (Patrick reporting; all should have finished the book by this time

Week 13 (04/22)

BW 269-284 Muhammad, TA poems 30-45, Murata, The Tao of Sufism, Muhammad trans. 2 (Jawad on Chittick on Cosmic Imagination)

Week 14 (04/29)

BW Muhammad, TA poems 45-61

 

 

Final Paper Due (non-seniors) in the Gest Center, 2nd Floor, May 11, 4PM

Note: the name of our author is Ibn al-`Arabi or, for short, Ibn `Arabi. "Ibn" or "Bin" or "Ben" means "son." If you drop the "Ibn" you are not giving the man's name; it would be like calling Johnson "John" or Thompson "Tom".