Prof. Anne McGuire
610 896-1028
amcguire@haverford.edu

The Parables of
Jesus
Religion 301a, Haverford College
Prof. Anne McGuire,
Fall 2009
COURSE DESCRIPTION:
This seminar will focus on a close study of the parables of Jesus in their
cultural and literary contexts. Special attention will be given to recent literary
analysis of the parables in the Synoptic Gospels and the Gospel of Thomas.
The parables of Jesus are found in the three synoptic gospels (Matthew, Mark,
and Luke) and the Gospel of Thomas. We will be studying all or most of the
parables found in these texts. Click here for a list
of the parables and a comparative table of
the gospel texts in which they appear. In our examination of these stories,
we'll consider their literary form and placement within each gospel and the
ways scholars of the New Testament and early Christianity have analyzed these
texts. Special attention will be given to recent literary analysis of the parables
in the Synoptic Gospels and the Gospel of Thomas.
New Testament scholars believe that Mark's gospel was the first gospel to
be written, and was used as a source by both Matthew and Luke. Matthew and
Luke also had access to other sources, both oral and written, for their accounts
of Jesus' teaching. One of these hypothesized sources is known as "Q" (for
German Quelle, or Source), and is usually taken to refer to material shared
by Matthew and Luke. But the parallel versions of the parables point to a more
complicated picture: some parables appear in all three NT gospels and Thomas;
some appear only in Matthew and Luke; some in Matthew and Thomas; some in Luke
and Thomas. Scholars of the synoptic problem are interested in these inter-relationships
and the formation of the gospel traditions in their oral and written form.
Our concern in this course is not so much with the sources, but with the analysis
and interpretation of the parables as individual stories, in different versions,
and as parts of larger compositions (i.e., Mark, Matt, Lk, Thomas). In this
course, we'll examine the parables as parts of these gospel texts, but we will
also consider their life as parabolic stories both before and after the writing
of the gospels. Most important, we'll consider our own contexts as scholars
and interpreters of the parables.
COURSE
REOUIREMENTS:
A. Weekly postings on the course's Discussion Board at the Blackboard
site (30%) and
active participation
in class discussion. This
is a seminar course. All students are expected to come prepared to participate
actively in discussion, to make presentations in class, and to respond
actively to others' presentations and comments.
B. Three 5-Page Papers with oral presentations (40%): Two of these
papers should offer a more sustained analysis of some aspects of the primary
and/or secondary texts assigned for class, together with an interpretive
argument about their significance. The third paper should focus on both primary
and secondary sources. This third paper, due the last day of class, 12/8, should
offer a close reading and analysis of a primary text together in the context
of a conversation with what other scholars have written about the material.
This paper should use footnotes to indicate the sources of the other scholars
with whom one is in conversation. This third paper may focus on a reading for
a previous class, an earlier post or paper, or it may contribute toward one's
completion of the final research paper.
- A
draft of the first two of these 5-page papers should be prepared by
the Tuesday evening before class and made available through Blackboard
or email.
- For class, each student
should prepare a brief oral presentation of the major points of the
paper, together with a selection of textual passages from both primary
and secondary sources, and questions for further discussion.
- In light of class discussion, these
papers should be revised and turned in by the next class. Dates for these
papers will be assigned by the second meeting of the seminar.
C. A Research
Paper of 15-18 pages (30%).
- Intermediate Due Dates
- Tuesday, November 10 - Hand in a brief statement
of your topic
- Tuesday, December 1 : Annotated bibliography
of 8-10 articles and books on your topic + Outline
- Optional: If you want feedback on a first draft, please
hand it in by F, December 4
REOUIRED
TEXTBOOKS:
- David B. Gowler, What Are They Saying About the Parables?
- Bernard Brendan Scott, Re-Imagine the World: An Introduction to the
Parables of Jesus
- Brad H. Young, The Parables: Jewish Tradition and Christian Interpretation
- John Dominic Crossan, In Parables: The Challenge of the Historical
Jesus
- Arland J. Hultgren, The Parables of Jesus: A Commentary
- The New Oxford Annotated Bible, NRSV
- Recommended: Gospel Parallels, ed. B.
Throckmorton
- The Historical Jesus in Context, Ed. by Amy-Jill Levine, Dale
Allison, John Dominic Crossan
- Links to Numerous Web Resources are included in the syllabus below.
Among the most useful are:
- Additional readings may be handed out in class or will be available online
or on Reserve in Magill Library
SYLLABUS OF
READINGS
9/1 Parables and Their Interpreters: Oral Tradition, Gospel Writers, Theologians,
NT Scholarship
9/8 From Oral Tradition to Written Texts; Case Study: The Parable of the
Sower and its Interpreters
- The Parables of Mark 4 and Its Parallels in Matthew 13, Luke, and Thomas
- Gowler, What are they Saying about the Parables?, 1-27
- Crossan, Speaking in Parables, 1-36
- Hultgren, The Parables of Jesus: A Commentary, 1-19; 453-61 (On the purpose
of Parables in Mark)
- Readings on the Parable of the Sower
- Amos Wilder, "Telling
from Depth to Depth: The Parable of the Sower," Jesus' Parables
and the War of Myths,
89-100 [pdf now available]
- J.D. Crossan, In Parables, 39-44
- Hultgren, The Parables of Jesus: A Commentary, 180-199
9/15 Parables and Figurative Speech in the Gospel of Mark
- The Gospel of Mark, read entire gospel with attention to its parables and
uses of figurative speech
- Readings on the Parables in Mark 4 and 12
- Hultgren, 351-370; 385-403
- Ched Myers, Binding the Strong Man,
20-38 (on a political reading strategy), 161-185 (on Mark 3-4); 308-323 (Mark
12)
- Crossan, In Parables, 86-96 (and review his reading of the Sower
9/29 Matthew's Parables: Seeds, Wheats and Tares; The Tenants and The Banquet
Parables; Parables Unique to Matthew
- Parables of Matthew 13 and their Parallels in GMark, GThomas. and GLuke.
Focus on Matthew's versions of the parables and how they fit into his gospel
- Parables of Matthew 13: The Parables of the
Sower, the
Mustard Seed, The Wheat and the Tares, the
Leaven, the Hidden Treasure, the Pearl, and the Net
- The Parable of the Tenants (Matt 21:33-46
with parallels)
- The Parable of the Wedding Banquet/Dinner;
Another Presentation of the 3 Versions
(Matt 22:1-14 with parallels in Luke 14:15-24, Thomas 64)
- Parables Unique to Matthew: The
Unmerciful Servant, The Laborers in the
Vineyard, The Two Sons, The
Ten Virgins
- Brad Young, Jewish Tradition and Christian Interpretation, 3-38
- Recommended:
The Diversity of Early Christianity, From Jesus to Christ web
site; Background reading on GMatthew
10/6 Looting the Strong Man's House: Parables and Figurative Speech in the
Gospel of Thomas
- The Parables of the Gospel of Thomas (Trans.
by S. Patterson and M. Meyer)
- The Gospel of Thomas - Read the entire gospel. There are various translations
of GThomas available online: Please read more than one of these:
FALL BREAK
10/20 The Parables of Luke
The Parables of Luke with some attention to their Parallels in GMark,
GMatthew, and GThomas. Focus on Luke's versions of the parables
and how they fit into his gospel
- Review the Lukan parallels to the parables of Mark 4 and Matthew 13 in
Luke 8:5-15 and 13:18-21
- The Parable of the Dinner; Another
Presentation of the 3 Versions (Luke
14:15-24, with parallels in Matt 22:1-14 and Thomas 64)
- The Parable of GLk 15: the Lost Sheep (Lk 15:3-7), the Lost Coin (Lk 15:8-1),
and the Prodigal Son (Luke 15:11-32 - unique to Lk)
- The Parable of the Talents (19:11-27), Wicked Tenants (Lk 20:9-18)
- Parables Unique to Luke : The Parables of: The Two Debtors
(7:41-47), The Good Samaritan (10:30-37), The Prodigal Son (15:11-43), The
Unjust Steward (16:1-8), The Rich Man and Lazarus (16:19-31)
- Read Relevant Sections in the Course Books (e.g., Hultgren, Scott, and
Crossan) on The Gospel of Luke
10/27 Missed Class to be made up on 11/24
11/3 The Work of J. D. Crossan, In Parables: The Challenge of the Historical
Jesus
11/10 B. Young, The Parables: Jewish Tradition and Christian
Interpretation
11/17 Part II, B. Young, The Parables: Jewish Tradition and Christian
Interpretation
11/24 The Jesus Seminar and B. B. Scott, Re-Imagine the
World: An Introduction to the Parables
- Scott, Re-Imagine the World
- Excerpts from the Jesus Seminar's Red Letter Edition of the Parables of Jesus
12/1 The Work of A. Hultgren, The Parables of Jesus: A Commentary
- Selections from Hultgren to be announced
12/8 Interpreting the Parables
-
Presentation of Work in Progress on Final Papers

Return to Dept.
of Religion Home Page
Return to Haverford
Academic Departments
This page is maintained by amcguire@haverford.edu,
Last updated 9/1/09