|
Last fall, McGovern fulfilled
his promise by introducing Political Science 325, Grassroots Politics
in Philadelphia, to the Haverford curriculum. The course gives students
at both Haverford and Bryn Mawr the opportunity to turn their education
into action by serving internships with g overnment
and non-profit agencies in Philadelphia and sharing their experiences
in the classroom.
The seeds of Grassroots Politics were planted in the fall of 2003, when
McGovern collaborated with fellows at Haverford House, a program in which
recent graduates live together in Philadelphia and volunteer at various
agencies around the city. “Some of them reached out to faculty members
interested in developing stronger ties between the College and city,”
says McGovern, who discussed with the fellows ideas for a course that
would connect students with Philadelphia non-profits. He fashioned a class
proposal that was approved by the faculty, and last summer he intensified
his search for appropriate organizations to host students as interns.
“I wanted a variety of organizations: government agencies to give
an insider’s perspective on urban politics and policy, public interest
groups and community-based organizations involved with grassroots organizing
so students will have opportunities to get out into the field and interact
with ordinary citizens mobilizing around issues critically important to
them and their neighborhoods,” he says. He was especially interested
in finding groups that covered issues related to housing and development,
education, poverty and welfare policy, and economic development: “In
my view these issues are absolutely central to the condition of American
cities today.”
He had an enthusiastic response from the organizations he contacted. “The
general consensus was, ‘Sure, I’d love to have a smart student
work here one day a week,’” he laughs. From the start, it
was important for him to make clear to the internship supervisors the
responsibilities involved: “In many cases this is the first real
work experience students will have. I wanted supervisors who were dependable,
reliable, who could mentor students, answer questions, and provide guidance.”
McGovern ended up selecting 15 organizations, one for each student who
pre-registered with the course. They include the Philadelphia Empowerment
Zone, a federally funded initiative that encourages economic development
in distressed neighborhoods; Public School Notebook, a newspaper published
several times a year dealing with contentious public education issues;
Empowerment Group, which cultivates local entrepreneurship in city communities;
and the Pennsylvania Economy League, a nonprofit public policy research
and development organization. He wanted students to have as broad a range
of experiences as possible and bring back to the classroom different kinds
of perspectives—even diametrically opposed views of one issue.
For example, he assigned students to several organizations associated
with the Neighborhood Transformation Initiative (NTI), an ambitious proposal
by Philadelphia mayor John Street to revitalize inner-city neighborhoods.
“In some ways it’s controversial,” says McGovern, who
has been conducting an academic study of NTI. “The city devotes
substantial resources to demolishing decaying structures, clearing land,
and getting private developers to build market-rate housing then sold
to middle-class residents. The program bolsters the city’s tax space,
and succeeds in fighting blight, but there are also question marks: How
many people have to be relocated, and what impact does this have on the
neighborhoods?” To examine NTI from all sides, he placed a student
with the city government agency responsible for implementing the project,
and sent others to organizations decidedly less supportive of the initiative.
“One is opposed to NTI because of the threat of displacement, believing
that not enough affordable housing would be constructed for low-income
residents,” he explains. “Other groups hold more moderate
views, and see both the benefits and the drawbacks of the plan. The idea
is that students work with these organizations, learn a lot about NTI
from different perspectives, and come back to the class and report about
their experiences.”
Grassroots Politics in Philadelphia is one of Haverford’s more demanding
courses. The seminar meets once a week on Monday evenings for two and
a half hours, and students are asked to commit eight hours a week to their
internships. “It’s a longer time commitment than a typical
course at Haverford or Bryn Mawr, and I went out of my way to alert students
to this fact,” says McGovern. “As a result, I ended up with
15 students who said this was exactly what they wanted. They knew it would
be tough but also an unusual, innovative opportunity. They’re a
terrific bunch of students, smart, highly motivated. It’s one of
the best classes I have ever had.”
In the first six weeks, students are given an introduction to urban politics
both in Philadelphia and across the country. Through assigned readings
they learn more about Philadelphia’s past and present hard times
and the ways in which American cities responded to the urban crisis of
the late 20th century. They also read Robert Fisher’s Let the People
Decide, a historical overview of organizing in American cities over the
last century, and Mark Warren’s Dry Bones Rattling: Community Building
to Revitalize American Democracy, which deals with contemporary grassroots
activism in Texas and the southeastern United States. “The readings
get students thinking about various strategies for mobilizing ordinary
folks, and what might and might not work in Philadelphia,” says
McGovern.
The second segment of the class focuses on policy issues, and the structure
of the course itself alters. “The first six weeks are traditional
in that the professor takes primary responsibility for assigning readings,”
says McGovern. “In the second segment students take more responsibility
for assigning articles and leading discussions.” During the last
six weeks the students take further control of the class content, offering
presentations on semester-long research projects growing out of their
internship experiences.
“This class builds upon students’ previous course work in
political science and urban studies,” says McGovern. “When
they get out into the field and experience the issues firsthand, those
issues come alive and take on greater meaning. They see the issues in
a different way, and have additional ideas about how to resolve them in
ways that even academics haven’t fully considered. They’re
on the cutting edge of strategies to revitalize American cities.”
Although the country’s urban landscapes still face some overwhelming
problems, the good news, according to McGovern, is that many cities have
stabilized over the last decade. Crime rates have fallen dramatically,
and “center city” districts are experiencing a revival (though
inner city neighborhoods are slower to improve). Citizens have taken a
greater interest in politics and become increasingly active in local government
through community-based organizing.
Among those active in Philadelphia’s revitalization—and whose
organizations are hosting McGovern’s students as interns—are
several Haverford alumni. David Thornburgh ’81 is executive director
of the Pennsylvania Economy League. Jenny Hamilton ’88 is executive
director of Afterschool Activities Partnerships. Andy Frishkoff ’88
is economic development director of the Philadelphia Empowerment Zone,
and became interested in issues of homelessness and poverty as a Haverford
student, when he was a weekly volunteer at a city shelter. “This
class gives students a greater understanding of community politics and
community-government interaction, removed from an ‘ivory tower’
approach,” he says. “It’s important for anyone interested
in cities to see what’s happening in communities; you have to look
at individuals and groups, not just books.”
Laura Gumpert ’02 is director of the Youth Entrepreneurship Program
at the Empowerment Group, and runs after-school business programs throughout
Philadelphia. “If there had been a class like this when I was a
student, I would have been very interested,” she says. “You
can read about case studies, about the challenges faced by city residents,
but you need to be exposed to the realities of what’s going on.”
She feels that it's a good experience for interns to come into Philadelphia
every week, to work in a low-income neighborhood, and become more comfortable
with the city in general. "Hopefully, this will encourage some students
to stay here after graduation."
McGovern has similar hopes for his Grassroots Politics in Philadelphia
students, believing that this early exposure to the inner sanctum of city
government and community organizing will encourage current Fords to become
future leaders in the quest to transform American cities. "I wouldn't
be surprised if, in five or 10 years, a number of the students taking
this class will be directors of public-interest groups themselves."
|