Physics 399 -- Senior Seminar - Fall 2008/Spring 2009

Fall Syllabus

Spring Syllabus

Meetings will be held Wednesdays 2:00-3:30 in KINSC L205, except for talks as noted.

All course readings and guidelines are posted on Blackboard

FALL TERM

Suzanne Amador Kane (office: KINSC L103, X1198, email: samador)

The physics faculty welcomes you to Senior Seminar! In this course you will practice writing a scientific paper; learn how to give a scientific presentation; hear lectures by eminent scientists and interact with them; learn more about careers available to you when you finish at Haverford; get into contact with alums who have gone in career directions of interest to you; learn about graduate school and how to go about selecting and applying to schools; and participate in discussions on topics relevant to science.

The course meets on many Wednesdays (2:00-3:30) throughout the semester, but with several other special events. Copies of all readings assigned in the course and other useful stuff as well are available in the Physics Lounge in the black binder marked Senior Seminar. A second binder contains listings of Haverford physics grads from years past, their present job titles and contact information. That binder also contains reports on some of those alums written by senior seminarians from previous years. You will find these to be very interesting.

Course Requirements (Fall)
• Attend all scheduled meetings of the seminar.
• Attend Philips visits and department colloquia. We hope you will also attend the informal meetings with our visitors. They enjoy talking with students and these informal gatherings are a great way to find out more about speaker and what he or she is up to.
• Read assigned selections and participate in class discussions.
• Contact two Haverford physics grads who are in non-academic jobs (you may include no more than one grad student), discuss their careers with them and prepare a one-page report and a brief (5-10 min.) presentation for the rest of the class. Reports will be graded only on a credit/no credit basis, but hand them on the date of the presentations for full credit. Also keep in mind that they will go into the binder, so following cohorts of physics seniors will be reading them. The presentations are scheduled for November 12, so you should begin the process of selection and contact as soon as possible.
• Write a short paper consisting of a preliminary version of the introduction and background sections of your senior paper (4-5 pages typically), a short (one page) progress report on the actual status of the project, and a bibliography that puts your work in its proper scholarly context. This is due at the end of the semester.
• Give a brief (10 min.) informal presentation to the seminar about the intro/background part of your senior paper project in early December.

Grading

You will receive one grade at the end of the academic year for Phys 399 as a whole. (The grade of CIP, course in progress, will besubmitted at the end of the fall semester provided all fall requirements were met.) The physics faculty working together assigns grades in the senior seminar according to the following approximate weighting factors:

 

Fall semester short paper & participation

25%

Quality of senior talk

35%

Senior paper (Spring semester)

40%

A reduction of 0.1 grade point will be applied per unexcused absence if more than one occurs per semester. (This includes attendance at required colloquia and senior talks.)

Approximate Fall Schedule

Wed. Sept. 3

Introduction; start of discussion of employment and careers;  alumni visit of Theo Posselt, Physics '99

Wed. Sept. 10 Graduate study (discussion with Beth Willman & Suzanne Amador Kane)

Wed. Sept. 17

Visit of Dr. Karen Spillane, Medical Physics Masters program, University of Pennsylvania
Wed. Sept. 24 Graduate study, alternative careers (with Peter Love & Suzanne Amador Kane)
Mon. Sept. 29;  Wed. Oct. 1

Bryn Mawr Physics Colloquium:  Karin Rabe, Rutgers University Physics Dept. (Condensed matter theory); free dinner at 5:30, talk at 6:30pm, Dorothy Vernon room, Haffner Hall, Bryn Mawr (see Suzanne for transportation);  No senior seminar meeting on Wed. this week.

Wed. Oct. 8 No meeting
Wed. Oct. 15 Fall Break; no meeting
Wed.. Oct. 22

Discussion of Scientific Ethics (with Walter Smith & Suzanne Amador Kane)

[Links to "Ethics in Science pages"]

Tues. Oct. 28 &

Wed. Oct. 29

Phillips visit of Robin Selinger, Chemical Physics, Kent State; regular senior seminar meeting with the visitor; talk on Tues. Oct. 28, H109, tea at 4:15, talk at 4:30.
Mon. Nov. 3;  Wed. Nov. 5

Mon. Nov. 3 David DeMille (Yale) AMO talk at Bryn Mawr;  free dinner at 5:30, talk at 6:30

Wed.Nov. 5:  No meeting (recovering from the election)

Wed. Nov. 12

Scientific speaking:  Read Advice to Beginning Physics Speakers;  we will also discuss these, but they are not assigned to read beforehand:  Woman Physicist's Guide to Speaking, What's Wrong with Those Talks? Do's and Don'ts of Poster PresentationsVideo:  Melissa Hines, Cornell, on public speaking  How to be a Good Audience at a Presentation

Chicken, Chicken, Chicken <---Don't do this!

Wed. Nov. 19

Writing & reading scientific papers:  Read the papers posted on Blackboard in the folder:  Writing (and Reading) Scientific Papers

Wed.. Nov. 26

No meeting (Start of Thanksgiving break)

Wed. Dec. 3 10 min. student presentations on senior paper introductions (all faculty supervisors): Joe Coish, Shea Garrison-Kimmel, Anna Klales, Andy O'Hara, Anna Pancoast
Wed. Dec. 10 10 min. student presentations on senior paper introductions (all faculty supervisors):  Monica Kishore, Greg Guthe, Colin Cross, Ella Willard-Schmoe, Munik Shrestha
Fri. Dec. 19 Introduction and preliminary bibliography due at 12:00 noon

SPRING TERM

Spring: Steve Boughn (office: Observatory, X1146, email: sboughn)

The physics and astronomy faculty welcomes you back to the spring semester of Senior Seminar!

In this semester, you will complete writing your Senior Paper, with feedback from two faculty members, and deliver your Senior Talk.

You are expected to participate in any departmental colloquia, and are encouraged to interact with our speakers through the luncheons, dinners and other opportunities for conversation.

Course Requirements (Spring)

*************************************

DRAFT SPRING SCHEDULE - Physics 399

January 21 First organizational meeting
January 28  

February 4

 
February 11  
February 18  
February 25  
March 4  
March 11 BREAK
March 16-20 APS March Meeting
March 18 Senior Talks (astronomy & physics double majors)
March 25 Senior Talks
March 27 Visit of Alex Rudolph (Astronomy talk);  Bruce Partridge Symposium on March 28
April 1 Senior Talks 
April 8 Senior Talks 
April 15 Senior Talks 
April 18 Saturday 5 p.m.; Firm deadline for first draft
April 23 Thursday: First reader returns revised first draft to student
April 29 Wednesday: Revised version of Senior Paper to first and second readers, noon
May 4 Monday: Check to see if additional changes are needed for the final version
May 7 Thursday: Final version submitted to first reader by noon

Senior Paper Readers:

Here are the first and second readers for your Senior Papers (draft):

 

Student

First reader Second reader
Joe Coish Bruce Partridge Steve Boughn
Colin Cross Walter Smith Suzanne Amador Kane
Shea Garrison-Kimmel Steve Boughn Beth Willman

Greg Guthe

Walter Smith

Suzanne Amador Kane

Monica Kishore

Jerry Gollub

Peter Love
Anna Klales Peter Love Stephon Alexander
Andy O'Hara Peter Love Stephon Alexander
Anna Pancoast Anna Sajina Beth Willman
Munik Shrestha Peter Love Stephon Alexander

Ella Willard-Schmoe

Suzanne Amador Kane /

Dale Winebrenner (UW)

Dale Winebrenner (UW)